Collins or Palmer?

[Perkeyset]

Carson Palmer is at chicago and Kerry Collins is at Philli

[sLim]

palmer...
philly will bring the exotic blitzes and collins will turn the ball over either with fumbles or ints...

[Grand Masta B]

i'm gonna say Collins, i'll be starting him over brady this week(going against Pit)

Mark my words: This is Rudi Johnson's week to shine, Palmer will get 1 td max.

[natedoggld182]

i think this is an easy one, go with palmer.

[JakeThompson]

Collins is the guy I'd go with. Philly will be able to score against this Oakland defense and Oakland will be forced to pass in the last quarter. Collins will be pressured and do stupid stuff like usual but he'll put up numbers. Rudi Johnson will see the ball a good deal against the Bears and Chicago actually has a pretty good defense.

Palmer: 250 yards, 1 TD
Collins: 325 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT

[sLim]

Originally Posted by JakeThompson

Collins is the guy I'd go with. Philly will be able to score against this Oakland defense and Oakland will be forced to pass in the last quarter. Collins will be pressured and do stupid stuff like usual but he'll put up numbers. Rudi Johnson will see the ball a good deal against the Bears and Chicago actually has a pretty good defense.

Palmer: 250 yards, 1 TD
Collins: 325 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT

u underestimate phillys defense...if u think chicago has a good D...how can u think phillys D isnt good?
they are one of the top 5 defenses in my opinion...
and they will bring the blitz like no other...backside...frontside...up the middle...

my predictions on collins this week:
215yards, 1td, 2ints, 2fumbles

[JakeThompson]

Originally Posted by sLim

u underestimate phillys defense...if u think chicago has a good D...how can u think phillys D isnt good?
they are one of the top 5 defenses in my opinion...
and they will bring the blitz like no other...backside...frontside...up the middle...

my predictions on collins this week:
215yards, 1td, 2ints, 2fumbles

Philly has the offense to get up big on Oakland and force Collins to pass a ton.

Chicago does not have the offense to score on Cincy. Cincy gets a quick TD or two and then grinds it out on the ground the rest of the game with Rudi.

[natedoggld182]

Originally Posted by sLim

my predictions on collins this week:
215yards, 1td, 2ints, 2fumbles

I think 4 TOs is a bit much, I do think collins will not a great day, and would rather start palmer.

[PiST0N]

I'd stick with Palmer.. Philly's blitz packages are too much for an immobile quarterback.. hell, they can even limit the most mobile (Vick). Too much for a quarterback that panics.

[sLim]

Originally Posted by JakeThompson

Philly has the offense to get up big on Oakland and force Collins to pass a ton.

Chicago does not have the offense to score on Cincy. Cincy gets a quick TD or two and then grinds it out on the ground the rest of the game with Rudi.

thats exactly what philly wants...force their opponents to go to the pass only option...their weakness is their run D...philly has one of the best secondaries in the NFL...they force u to pass...and they will bring exotic blitzes to cause u to force the ball into turnovers...

teams that beat phillys defenses last year ran all over them...nobody really beat them thru the air...